RE: Jariwala SK. Is radical prostate cancer radical? ANZ J Surg 2010; 80: 570-571
We read with interest this correspondence from Dr Jariwala1 and would like to highlight our difference of opinion on some of the key points.
Although we talk about fundamental oncological principals, in fact the heterogeneity of malignant tumours necessitates widely differing surgical approaches. Using the example of testis cancer aforementioned in the letter, lymph nodes are not routinely removed when performing a radical orchidectomy as although this would adhere to "oncological principles", the additional morbidity of retroperitoneal surgery would be unjustified in the majority of cases. Therefore calling it a radical operation may be a misnomer, but it is still the correct cancer operation.
Clearly some tumours, e.g. sarcoma, require extensive excision to optimise cure rate, however, one must remember that the patient has to live with the surgical sequelae. Therefore optimization of functional outcome while achieving oncological control has driven the evolution of many cancer operations. The refinements in breast cancer surgery from radical mastectomy to lumpectomy is evidence of this move away from radical surgery for the sake of it.
With regards to radical prostatectomy, we agree that the intrafascial nerve sparing technique has the potential to increase the positive surgical margin rates. However, the anatomical figure illustrating Dr Jariwala’s letter over-simplifies the fascial layers surrounding the prostate and is anatomically incomplete. It has been demonstrated that there is fusion of the fascial layers posteriorly and that although an intrafascial plane can be developed between the prostate and Denonvilliers posteriorly, this is a difficult plane which can be perilously close to peripheral tumours. The interfascial and extrafascial planes are essentially the same posteriorly, which is the cause of some confusion . Our own preference is to perform an interfascial dissection2 and this is predicated on sound anatomic principles which we have recently revisited3 (Figure 1).
Figure 1: A graphical illustration of the peri-prostatic anatomy following cadaveric dissections. Adapted from Costello et al with permission3.
A critical analysis of the current surgical prostatic anatomy is eloquently described by Walz et al and demonstrates excellent schematics of this area4.
Robin Weston MB ChB FRCS(Urol)
Department of Urology, Royal Melbourne Hospital, Parkville, Victoria, Australia
Declan G Murphy MB FRCS(Urol)
The Peter MacCallum Cancer Centre, East Melbourne, Victoria, Australia
Anthony J Costello MD FRACS FRCSI(hon) MBBS
Department of Urology, Royal Melbourne Hospital, Parkville, Victoria, Australia
References
1. Jariwala SK. Re: Is radical prostatectomy radical? ANZ J Surg, 80: 570, 2010.
2. Murphy DG, Kerger M, Crowe H, Peters JS and Costello AJ. Operative Details and Oncological and Functional Outcome of Robotic-Assisted Laparoscopic Radical Prostatectomy: 400 Cases with a Minimum of 12 Months Follow-up. Eur Urol, 55: 1358, 2009.
3. Costello AJ, Dowdle B, Namdarian B, Pedersen J, and Murphy DG. Immunohistochemical study of the cavernous nerves in the periprostatic region. BJU Int, In Press: 2010.
4. Walz J, Burnett AL, Costello AJ, Eastham JA, Graefen M, Guillonneau B et al. A Critical Analysis of the Current Knowledge of Surgical Anatomy Related to Optimization of Cancer Control and Preservation of Continence and Erection in Candidates for Radical Prostatectomy. Eur Urol, 57: 179, 2010.