Opinions
Re: Discussion: A case of a neuropathic diabetic foot ulcer causing rupture of the Achilles tendon
We thank Behan et al. for their comments pertaining to value of reconstructive surgery in this case of a neuropathic ulcer causing rupture of Achilles tendon. Management of the diabetic foot is always associated with interesting challenges, which are increasingly being dealt with in a holistic multidisciplinary manner. The purpose of our case report was to simply highlight an unusual cause of rupture of the Achilles tendon, and not to enter into a discussion of the management of diabetic foot ulcers.
Our approach to the management of diabetic foot ulcers occurs in a multidisciplinary manner within our tertiary institute (vascular surgery, podiatry, endocrinology, nursing, infectious disease and orthopaedic surgical involvement). Reconstructive surgery is considered with plastic surgeon consultation on case-by-case basis. This is done after all issues including removal of infected tissue and long-term function are taken into account. In this particular case, the patient had significant co-morbidities, particularly a poor cardiac reserve with an ejection fraction of 11% and an implantable defibrillator. Despite not having a reconstruction, she had a very good outcome with respect to healing of the wound and functional capacity.
Hafees Saleem,*† MB BS, MRCSEd
Sheri L. Newman,* MB BS
Phillip J. Puckridge,*† MB BS, FRACS (Vascular Surgery)
J. Ian Spark,*† FRCS, MD, FRCS (Gen), FRACS, PG Cert Medical US
*Department of Vascular Surgery, Flinders Medical Centre & Repatriation General Hospital, and
†Department of Surgery, Flinders University, Bedford Park, South Australia, Australia
0 comments - Leave a comment
Re: Diagnostic evaluation and management of benign duodenal tumours (ANZ J. Surg. 2010; 80: 526–30)
We read the article by Ji-Qi Yan and colleagues with great interest.1 As reports on benign duodenal tumours are rare, it is important to learn how others treat these rare entities. The article nonetheless raised a number of questions.
In the methods section,Yan and colleagues state that the benignity of tumours was confirmed by post-operative pathology. It would be interesting to know if they took preoperative biopsies in all cases, in how many cases they suspected a malignancy and whether this affected their treatment decision. Since the number of minimal repairs compared to radical resection with pancreaticoduodenectomy (PD) was quite high, it seems that in most cases, benign lesions were suspected. Endoscopic ultrasound (EUS) could have been used in the preoperative assessment, too. EUS is an important diagnostic tool since it is known that EUS is a sensitive and specific method for tumour and nodal staging.2 If in the preoperative assessment there were cases where malignancy was suspected, it would be interesting to know whether these were the cases treated with PD. This leads to the question of exactly when they chose a particular procedure, aware that in case of doubt, the more radical option would be the better one.3 Flow charts have proved to be useful in the management of tumours,4 and one wonders whether they used a particular flow chart or algorithm. (Click here to continue reading.)
0 comments - Leave a comment
Re: A case of a neuropathic diabetic foot ulcer causing rupture of the Achilles tendon
We read with interest the case reported by Saleem et al. in which a diabetic ulcer of the posterior leg progressed to rupture of the Achilles tendon.1 While the case was interesting in its presentation, we would like to comment on the ultimate management of the patient, who underwent debridement of the ulcer but no formal reconstruction of either the ulcer or the Achilles tendon. We feel that consideration of relatively simple reconstructive options can substantially impact on quality of life in the increasingly common presentation of diabetic leg ulcers. (Click here to continue reading.)
1 comments - Leave a comment
Re: Author response: criticism of ASOHNS guidelines is incorrect (Re: ANZ. J. Surg. 80: 480–2)
The stated objective in Dr SV Fernandes’ letter of reply1 differs from that stated in his previously published article.2
In his article, Dr SV Fernandes states, ‘The guidelines for evaluation of noise-induced hearing loss (NIHL) suggest that in cases of asymmetry, “the worse ear be equated to the better ear” for purposes of compensation. This method is prejudicial to theworker (plaintiff).’ His letter of reply states, ‘The objective of my article was to view the current recommended practice of equating the worse ear to the better ear in cases where an asymmetry sufficient to warrant retrocochlear investigation is shown, in the context of legal proceedings’. (Click here to continue reading.)
0 comments - Leave a comment
- ANZJSurg.com blog
- 22 December 2010
Re: Prasad S, Wilson J, Kalade A, Desmond P, Chen R. Endoscopic ultrasound of pancreatic cystic lesions. ANZ J Surg 2010; 80: 600-604
I read this article with great interest. Cystic lesions in the pancreas are being increasingly recognized. 1.2% of 24309 CT or MRI studies reviewed at the Wisconsin Medical College revealed cystic lesion in the pancreas1. The primary aim of diagnosis is to differentiate benign from malignant. Findings which suggest potentially malignant tumors are: cyst fluid contains mucin, high CEA, high viscosity, and biopsy reveals mucin secreting cells2. A recent history of pancreatitis, amylase-rich fluid, and communication with the pancreatic duct suggests pseudocyst. CEA in cystic fluid is a good marker and helps to distinguish mucinous cystadenoma (MCN) from serous cystadenoma (SCN). SCAs have very low levels of CEA, with the cut-off value being 5ng/ml3. The authors mentioned that the benefit of prophylactic antibiotics is unknown. I would like to state here that EUS–FNA, from pseudocyst or cystic tumors, is at increased risk of infectious complications and antibiotic prophylaxis is recommended4, 5.
Dr Vipul D Yagnik MBBS MS FMAS
Ronak Endo-laparoscopy and General Surgical Hospital, Patan, Gujarat, India
References
1. Spinelli KS, Fromwiller TE, Daniel RA, Kiely JM, Nakeeb A, Komorowski RA, et al. Cystic pancreatic neoplasms: observe or operate. Ann Surg 2004; 239:651-9.
2. Brugge WR, Lewandrowski K, Lee-Lewandrowski E, et al: Diagnosis of pancreatic cystic neoplasms: A report of the cooperative pancreatic cyst study. Gastroenterology 2004; 126:1330-1336.
3. Hammel P, Levy P, Voitot H, et al: Preoperative cyst fluid analysis is useful for the differential diagnosis of cystic lesions of the pancreas. Gastroenterology 108. 1230 1995.
4. Adler DG, Jacobson BC, Davila RE et al. ASGE guideline: complications of EUS. Gastrointest. Endosc. 2005; 61: 8-12. Erratum in: Gastrointest. Endosc. 2005; 61: 502.
5. American Society for Gastrointestinal Endoscopy: Guideline on antibiotic prophylaxis for GI endoscopy. Gastrointest Endosc 2008; 67:791-8.
2 comments - Leave a comment
- ANZJSurg.com blog
- 21 December 2010
Re: Criticism of ASOHNS Guidelines incorrect.
I thank Dr. B. Williams for his comments. However his response seems to have missed the point entirely.
The objective of my article1 was to view the current recommended practice of equating the worse ear to the better ear in cases where an asymmetry sufficient to warrant retrocochlear investigation is shown, in the context of legal proceedings. Most ENT surgeons would be aware of the pathology yield in cases of ‘asymmetric hearing loss sufficient to warrant retrocochlear investigation’ in routine clinical practice. The medical literature is also rife with such experience. In other words in the real world, asymmetric hearing loss is common, identifiable pathology is not.
The Worker’s Compensation Legislation allows the medical expert to provide an opinion based on ‘the preponderance of evidence’ standard (civil). This means that no hard proof is required for establishing a link but that other factors can allow a conclusion to be reached. In cases where the probability (greater than 0.5) exists that noise is a substantial factor (more likely than not) in the causation of the asymmetry, the legal process allows the expert to infer so. Here we need to note that a medicolegal opinion is not the same as a medical diagnosis2. (Click here to continue reading.)
0 comments - Leave a comment
- ANZJSurg.com blog
- 20 December 2010
RE: Jariwala SK. Is radical prostate cancer radical? ANZ J Surg 2010; 80: 570-571
We read with interest this correspondence from Dr Jariwala1 and would like to highlight our difference of opinion on some of the key points.
Although we talk about fundamental oncological principals, in fact the heterogeneity of malignant tumours necessitates widely differing surgical approaches. Using the example of testis cancer aforementioned in the letter, lymph nodes are not routinely removed when performing a radical orchidectomy as although this would adhere to "oncological principles", the additional morbidity of retroperitoneal surgery would be unjustified in the majority of cases. Therefore calling it a radical operation may be a misnomer, but it is still the correct cancer operation.
Clearly some tumours, e.g. sarcoma, require extensive excision to optimise cure rate, however, one must remember that the patient has to live with the surgical sequelae. Therefore optimization of functional outcome while achieving oncological control has driven the evolution of many cancer operations. The refinements in breast cancer surgery from radical mastectomy to lumpectomy is evidence of this move away from radical surgery for the sake of it. (Click here to continue reading.)
0 comments - Leave a comment
- ANZJSurg.com blog
- 20 December 2010
Re: Hugh TB. Chappel v Hart: res judicata? ANZ J Surg. 80: 576 and Hugh TB. Surgical Sense and Legal Non-Sense – Chappel v Hart revisited. ANZ J Surg 79: 554-557
I applaud Dr TB Hugh on his article1 and letter2. I add a system error perspective.
The issue is, was there a failure to warn of the risk of R vocal cord palsy (VCP) in 1983; not whether there was a breach in 1994 when the trial occurred.
I agree the incidence of R VCP due to a Dohlman operation before 1983 was not established at trial and I agree it was zero; unlike the known incidence of 1:14,000 in Rogers v Whitaker. With respect, even the trial judge’s objected question was not referenced to the period before 1983. Expert opinion after 1983 or in 19913 is not relevant. It is probable the expert opinion quoted in 1994 as “vocal cord paralysis has been described” referred to Dr Benjamin’s 1991 article3 which is presumed to be Mrs Hart. There was no evidence as to the incidence of R VCP before 1983. (Click here to continue reading.)
0 comments - Leave a comment
- ANZJSurg.com blog
- 24 November 2010
Re: Fernandes SV. Asymmetric hearing loss in industry. ANZ J. Surg. 80: 480-482
Dr Fernandes has made a serious criticism of the Australian Society of Otolaryngology Head and Neck Surgery (ASOHNS) Guidelines for Evaluation of Occupational Noise Induced Hearing Loss (ONIHL) of Gradual Process (2nd Edition)1. He states they are “prejudicial to the worker (plaintiff)” and “unjustly favour the employer” because they “suggest that in cases of asymmetry, ‘the worse ear be equated to the better ear’ for purposes of compensation” and the “improbability of a non-NIHL in asymmetric cases”.
In fact the ASOHNS Guidelines do not “suggest that in cases of asymmetry, ‘the worse ear be equated to the better ear’”. They state under the heading Interpretation:
“In cases of asymmetry of sensorineural loss sufficient to warrant retro-cochlear investigation but otherwise consistent with NIHL, the worse ear is equated to the better.” (My emphasis.)
This paragraph must be read with the full guidelines, especially Diagnosis below. The phrase “consistent with” is not a diagnosis and it is too speculative to use it as a positive indicator of actual NIHL. Adelman2 reports the Workers Compensation Board of British Columbia found 10 claimants over a 5 year period had undiagnosed acoustic tumours. (Click to continue reading.)
0 comments - Leave a comment
Re: Slattery D. Dupuytren’s disease in Asia and the migration theory of Dupuytren’s disease. ANZ J Surg 2010; 80: 495-499.
This useful literature review, which draws attention to the migration theory of the incidence of Dupuytren’s contracture and discusses occurrences of the condition in East Asian countries, appropriately argues against causation by sporadic genetic mutation, but other aspects of the following conclusion are less convincingly argued: ‘This review shows that there is a low but significant incidence of DD across Asia, which supports the hypothesis of a widespread genetic susceptibility to the disease. Therefore, the prevalence of DD in this community is not likely due to sporadic genetic mutation as previously presumed’ (did many people think this?) ‘but rather individual genetic susceptibility and that risk factors play a major role in the expression of DD in this population.’
It seems that it is felt relevant that there is a positive family history of the disease in only 9% of afflicted Asians, but in any population many people whose Dupuytren’s diathesis is mild and whose disease first appears late in life lack a positive family history. Apart from a positive family history, no evidence is put forwards that the cited risk factors – diabetes, trauma, epilepsy, alcoholism and manual labour – play a greater role in countries where the incidence of the disease is low than where it is high.
An alternative explanation is that fewer genes responsible for Dupuytren’s contracture have reached Asia, and that Asian genetic pools are less likely to allow expression of the genes of Dupuytren’s contracture.
Some risk factors, including alcoholism, are widely accepted but others, such as manual work, are still hotly debated. I think it is fair to say that most hand surgeons believe manual work to have little influence upon the causation of Dupuytren’s contracture.
John A Buntine FRACS
Box Hill Hospital, Box Hill, Victoria, Australia
0 comments - Leave a comment